The Individual Bondholders Forum (IBF) has proposed some fiscal measures they say can help government save ¢83.5 billion cedis, insisting the Ministry of Finance must not touch their funds.
According to the group, government can save ¢20 billion from privatizing selected State Owned Enterprises to Tier-2 pension funds to drive efficiency and productivity.
“The measures proposed, per the estimation of the IBF yield net savings of ¢83.5 billion. The IBF holds the position that the recommendations are competent enough to urgently address the fiscal challenges and enable us to reach the desired 55% debt-to-GDP target proposed to the IMF”, a statement signed by Senyo Hosi, Convener of the IBF, and Samuel Arkhurst, Director at the Ministry of Finance said.
The statement was issued by the Government of Ghana-Individual Bondholders’ Forum Technical Committee on the Exclusion of Individual Bondholders from the Domestic Debt Exchange Programme.
Providing some more recommendations, the IBF said that the budget provision for the energy sector shortfall of ¢23 billion should be revised downwards by ¢3 billion through the reduction of transmission losses, technical losses, and administrative inefficiencies.
They also stated that government must maintain the 2022 capital expenditure level by reducing the non-Annual Budget Funding Amount (ABFA), Municipal and District Assembly budget and foreign finance of Capital Expenditure by 50 percent.
“Cap the subsidies on the premix petroleum at ¢200 million thereby reducing the budget by ¢150 millon. Owing to the wanton abuse of this subsidy, provide discount coupons to registered fisherfolks for the purchase of premix”.
The IBF advised government to also pursue the recovery of funds lost through financial irregularities of MDAs in the Auditor General’s Reports from 2015 to 2022. That exercise they say could bring in ¢13.9 billion.
In the oil and gas sector, the group stated that oil production has dropped from over 200kbpd to below 160kbpd yield revenue loss more than $300mn (GHS3.6bn) in 2022.
“The government should, as a matter of urgency, review the regulatory and fiscal environment to encourage existing producers to ramp up production and develop new fields”.
“Government should exercise its right under the Aker petroleum agreement (Deepwater Tano) to repossess the block or compel the immediate commencement of development by the contractor. This field has the potential of delivering up to 100kbpd yielding over GHS5.6bn per year to the government”, it added.
To increase revenue, the IBH urged government to expedite reforms to enforce property taxes.
It suggested that “with landed properties of circa 2,200,000 in Ghana (Ghana Population and Housing Census 2021), we anticipate that achieving an average annual rate of ¢1,000 per property at a collection efficiency of 50%, will yield the government over ¢1.1 billion in revenue”.
“Rise above politics and fully enforce the VAT invigilation that saw the rise of VAT revenue by 1000% in some cases. This assumes a 15% over the 2023 estimated VAT collection of ¢23.7 billion”, the statement said.
The Ghana cedi held steady against the US dollar last week as soft US inflation data caused the American greenback to weaken against a basket of emerging market currencies, including the local unit.
As a result, the cedi gained 0.13% week-on-week to end the week’s trades at a mid-rate of GH¢15.93 to a dollar.
However, robust economic data from the Eurozone and the UK caused the pound and the euro to strengthen, resulting in the cedi shedding 0.86% week-on-week and 0.58% week-on-week against the pound and the euro.
Meanwhile, the cedi would gain some respite from the Bank of Ghana’s 7-day Forward Auction Initiative this week.
The Bank of Ghana (BoG) announced a seven-day forward auction last week, where banks and authorised foreign exchange dealers could submit bids to purchase foreign currencies, with a settlement date set to seven days after the auction.
Analysts believe this development seeking to replace the spot market intervention, will also augment the Bulk Oil Distributing Companies auction and help tame demand pressures on the market.
During the maiden auction last week, the BoG sold about $53 million which helped the local unit to gain 0.29% day-on-day vs the American greenback.
Against the backdrop of this initiative, analysts see room for the cedi to remain fairly stable in the coming weeks.
Meanwhile, one dollar is going for GH¢15.90 on the retail market.
So far, the dollar has lost about 23% to the dollar on the retail market since January 1, 2024.
The Ghana Cedi is expected to recover some losses against the dollar in the coming months, Fitch Solutions has disclosed.
According to the London-based firm, this is due to enhanced investor confidence, increased dollar inflows, and easing external conditions.
In an article titled “Sub-Saharan Africa Currency Round-Up: Greater Stability Ahead in Second Half of 2024,” it is predicted that external conditions will provide more support to Sub-Saharan African currencies in the coming quarters.
The London-based ratings agency expects the Ghanaian cedi to perform better in the second half of 2024. So far this year, the cedi has lost approximately 20% of its value against the US dollar, making it one of the worst-performing currencies globally.
Weak capital inflows due to subdued market sentiment and ongoing debt restructuring negotiations have contributed to this decline. However, the start of an economic recovery, with real GDP growth accelerating from 3.8% in Q4 2023 to 4.7% year-on-year in Q1 2024, has increased demand for foreign exchange.
Ghana’s international reserves remain low, covering just 2.5 months of imports as of March. Along with IMF agreements allowing the exchange rate to adjust to market conditions.
Fitch Solutions projects that the cedi will regain value by 9.0% by year-end, from the July 9, 2024, spot.
On July 8, Ghana reached an agreement with international bondholders to restructure US$13 billion worth of external debt. This process is expected to be concluded by the end of September 2024.
Fitch Solutions stated that: “this restructuring will improve investor sentiment towards Ghana, enhance capital inflows, and apply appreciatory pressure on the cedi”.
A new report by the World Bank has revealed that Ghana was the second top recipient of remittances in sub Saharan Africa in 2023. In 2022, Ghana recorded $4.7 billion in remittances occupying the second position in that year.
This was captured in the 2023 Migration and Development report released by bank on June 26, 2024.
According to the report, the largest recipients of remittances in the period under review in US dollar terms were Nigeria, followed by Ghana, Kenya, and Zimbabwe.
Nigeria received $19.5 billion, Ghana $4.6 billion, Kenya $4.2 billion and Zimbabwe $2.1 billion.
The report pointed out that remittances have become the most important foreign exchange earner in most countries in sub Saharan Africa.
“For example, for Kenya remittances are larger than the country’s key exports, including tourism, tea, coffee, and horticulture. Countries more dependent on receipts as a proportion of GDP include the Gambia, Lesotho, Comoros, Liberia, and Cabo Verde with remittances contributing more than a fifth of GDP in the first three countries”, it said.
The World Bank explained thatremittance flows to Sub-Saharan Africa were nearly 1.5 times the size of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) flows in 2023, and relatively more stable.
Over all, the report said that the regional growth in remittances in 2023 was largely driven by strong remittance growth in Uganda (15 percent to $1.4 billion), Rwanda (9.3 percent to $0.5 billion), Kenya (2.6 percent to $4.2 billion), and Tanzania (4 percent to $0.7 billion). Remittances to Nigeria, accounting for around 35 percent of total remittance inflows to the region, decreased by 2.9 percent to $19.5 billion.
Remittance costs
The report revealed that sub-Saharan Africa remained the region with the highest remittance costs. Senders had to pay an average of 7.9 percent to send $200 to African countries during 2023Q4, compared with 7.4 percent in 2022Q4.
Costs vary substantially across the region, ranging from 2.1–4.0 percent in the lowest-cost corridors to 18–36 percent in the highest.
Intraregional remittances costs are still very high. For example, sending $200 in remittances from Tanzania to neighboring Kenya, Uganda, and Rwanda cost a migrant more than 33 percent in 2023Q4.